Saturday, August 9, 2014

Leading the Witness


Mark 10:17
      Have you ever buttered someone up before asking them a question for which you wanted a favorable answer? You put the big smile on your face and engage in small pleasantries before asking for that favor. Or maybe you just compliment them on something they are wearing, or on their work or support in the past. You purposely try to get them in a good mood, lift their spirits, before you ask.
      There isn’t anything necessarily wrong with this, except there is an element of manipulation in the actions. You can tell you are manipulating if these gestures only happen when you are trying to get something out of the other person. I think it is this personality shift that signals you are manipulating.
      I wonder if the man in our text was buttering Jesus up. He does run up to him, showing the urgency of his request, perhaps even some eagerness to get an answer. He then falls on his knees, a sign of submission. He is the lesser person kneeling before the greater, Jesus. Surely this would indicate at least he know to get his outward in line with his question. His outward actions certainly seem to show that he wants to know the answer to his question.
      If you were watching this man’s actions from a distance, it would seem as if he was getting it right. He didn’t come demanding an answer. He was, after all, a member of the wealthy class. He had certain standing in the community. People often provided him with what he needed. He could well afford to buy the best and demand the best service. If he didn’t like the way he was treated, he could take his business elsewhere. There were other people who would gladly take his money.
      And then he opens his mouth. On the surface these words don’t seem so bad. If they were asked to any ordinary teacher, they would be perfectly acceptable. Perhaps this man had asked this same question of all the influential teachers of his day. Maybe Jesus is just the next in the line of teachers. We don’t know. He does come to Jesus.
      It is interesting to see how he frames the question. He wants to know the ‘do’ of eternal life’s prerequisites. He has been taught all his life that if you do certain things, you are a shoe in for heaven. Just complete the right list of do’s and don’t’s and you get in. Is he looking for Jesus’ list?
      Were his actions rehearsed like the now famous rant, “What difference does it make?” Is he willing to take responsibility for his actions in the past, or will he just point fingers at others? Is his request genuine, or just another attempt at earning what can’t be earned?